After reading the
different variations of the tale of Snow White and watching the movie
Blancanieves, I realized that all of the stories are still pretty similar in a
sense. However, I found the Brothers Grimm version to be the most similar
to the silent film. Although Blancanieves incorporates a different theme
with the bullfighting aspect, one can still understand where the tale of Snow
White comes into play. The Brothers Grimm tale is different in the sense
that a king and queen are involved instead of a bullfighting champion and his
wife; however, both of the men's roles indicate that they are men of power and
wealth. Both stories include the first wife dying during childbirth, and
the husband remarrying a woman who becomes the "evil stepmother."
A main difference between both stories is that in the Brothers Grimm tale, Snow
White's father does not play a big role at all, unlike in the movie. In
the movie, we see a real connection form between the young girl and her now
paralyzed father. Also, in the Brothers Grimm story, the mirror on the
wall is a huge part in the tale and why the evil stepmother wants to kill Snow
White, very similar to the Disney movie. In the movie Blancanieves,
Encarna's chauffeur is sent out to kill Carmen and actually believes he does
kill her; however, in the Brothers Grimm tale, the huntsman pities her and
spares her life. One major similarity between the movie and the Grimm
tale is that the seven dwarfs play a huge role in protecting Snow White and
saving her life. Something we did not see in Blancanieves is the evil
stepmother repeatedly trying to kill the young lady until she tries to poison
her with the apple at the end, (because for all this time she thinks she is
dead, until she sees her as a matador in a magazine). The poisonous apple
is a huge symbol in both stories; however, the stories' endings go down two
separate paths, one being a happy ending with prince charming saving Snow
White, the other ending in her death. Although both stories are both very
different, the overall premise of the tales is very similar, and anyone could
recognize that Blancanieves has many references from the classic tale of Snow
White. I think that both tales were very fascinating, and I especially
loved how the film totally depicted the tale in a different way.
I do agree that in Blancanieves, the most heartwarming part of it was the special bond between father and daughter. In the beginning, after Carmen's mother's death, it seemed that the father shunned Carmen. However, we find out that it isn't true in the duration of the movie.
ReplyDeleteThe mirror on the wall helped Snow White's stepmother seem more crazy. It was a tool to gauge her anger and it fueled her determination as she tried to kill her stepdaughter.
ReplyDelete